How to Build a Great Reputation as a Spare Goalie

In the world of adult rec hockey, rent-a-goalies are essential. But the best ones? They’re not just reliable — they’re requested by name. If you're a spare goalie looking to stand out and get booked consistently, building a great reputation is the key.

Here are the steps to becoming a 5-star goalie teams want back every time.

1. Be On Time, Every Time

Teams are already stressed when their regular goalie cancels. Don’t add to their anxiety by showing up late. Arrive at least 30 minutes before puck drop to get dressed, meet the team, and hit the ice with confidence.

2. Communicate Clearly

Respond quickly to game requests and confirm any key details like rink location, dressing room, or team jersey colour.

Pro Tip: Use the MyPuck.com messaging feature to clarify details well before game time.

3. Play Hard, Regardless of the Score

You might find yourself on teams with weak defense or chaotic systems. No matter what, give your best effort. Teams appreciate goalies who compete and don’t give up, even if it’s 8-2.

4. Stay Positive and Chill

Your attitude in the room matters as much as your play on the ice. Be friendly, respectful, and don’t chirp teammates for mistakes.

5. Keep Your Gear Clean and Professional

Well-maintained gear shows you take your role seriously. Clean, odor-free pads and a professional setup go a long way.

6. Support the Team

Even if you don’t know the players, act like part of the squad:

• Communicate on the ice

• Tap gloves after periods

• Congratulate them after big plays

7. Ask for Reviews

After the game, ask the team to leave a review on MyPuck.com. Positive ratings boost your visibility and help you get more bookings.

Related: How to become a rent-a-goalie

8. Know Your Level and Own It

Play within your skill range. Don’t book into A-level games if you're not ready. Protect your rep by playing smart and safe.

9. Stay Available

The more you play, the more you get booked. Set your availability on MyPuck so teams can see when you’re ready.

10. Be a Teammate, Not Just a Goalie

Goalies who hang out post-game, say thanks, and maybe share a beer in the parking lot become part of the beer league culture. That’s what builds loyalty.

Final Thoughts

A great reputation brings more games, more fun, and more income. Be dependable, respectful, and dialed in every time you hit the ice.

Want to become a goalie everyone loves to book? Join the MyPuck network today