How Much Does It Cost to Rent a Goalie in Canada?
If you’ve ever scrambled to find a goalie for your adult rec hockey game, you know the panic — but how much should you expect to pay when you book a rent-a-goalie? Here’s a breakdown of what it costs to hire a spare goalie through services like MyPuck.com, plus what you’re actually paying for.
Typical Cost to Rent a Goalie
In Canada, you can expect to pay anywhere from $40 to $80 per game when you rent a goalie through a reputable service. The price depends on:
✅ Your location: Major cities like Toronto, Calgary, or Vancouver may have more demand and slightly higher rates.
✅ Skill level: An experienced goalie for a competitive men’s league might cost more than one for a casual shinny game.
✅ Time and day: Late-night or early-morning games may cost extra.
Related: How renting a goalie works
What’s Included in the Fee?
Your fee covers:
The goalie’s time and travel.
Their equipment and upkeep (goalie gear is expensive!).
The platform’s matching and vetting.
Peace of mind for your team — no more last-minute forfeits.
You pay securely online with no awkward cash handoffs at the rink.
Why It’s Worth It
Renting a goalie can save your whole team’s ice time — and the cost is tiny compared to what you’d lose in forfeit fees, wasted rink time, and disappointed teammates.
Plus, most teams split the cost. Ten players paying $6–$8 each? Worth it every time.
Are There Extra Fees?
Most reputable services like MyPuck.com keep it simple — what you see is what you pay. There are no surprise charges. Just make sure you book through the platform to guarantee your goalie shows up.
Should You Tip a Spare Goalie?
Tips aren’t required, but they’re always appreciated — especially for last-minute saves or great performances. Many teams buy the rent-a-goalie a beer after the game — it’s hockey etiquette!
How to Keep Costs Down
✅ Book in advance: Last-minute bookings can cost more.
✅ Be clear about your level: Don’t overpay for an elite goalie if you’re a casual beer league.
✅ Use a trusted service: Book your goalie at MyPuck.com and avoid hidden fees.
Keeping Adult Hockey Alive
Renting a goalie isn’t just about keeping your game alive — it’s about supporting local hockey goalies, many of whom are ex-competitive players who love staying on the ice.
Related: Top 5 reasons to hire a spare goalie
The Bottom Line
When your goalie cancels, don’t panic — just book a reliable spare goalie and keep the beer league dream alive. For the cost of a round of beers, you’ll never miss a game again.
Need a goalie? Find one here