The Dos and Don’ts of Renting a Goalie: Team Etiquette and Expectations

Renting a goalie can save your beer league game — but there’s an unspoken etiquette that makes the experience better for everyone. Whether you’re new to hiring a spare goalie or a veteran team, here are the dos and don’ts to follow when using MyPuck.com or any rent-a-goalie service.

✅ DO: Be Honest About Your Skill Level

When you book a goalie, be accurate about your team’s level of play. If you’re a low-level beer league, don’t say you’re high-level competitive. A goalie who expects a hard skate might be disappointed, or vice versa. Honest info helps everyone have a good time.

Related: How renting a goalie works

✅ DO: Communicate Clearly

Send the goalie clear details: rink name, dressing room, team colours, puck drop time, and any quirks about the rink. Good communication means no surprises.

✅ DO: Be On Time

Goalies often play multiple games in a night. If your game runs late because your team isn’t ready, it can mess up their schedule.

✅ DO: Treat Them Like a Teammate

Welcome your rent-a-goalie just like you would your regular goalie. Introduce them to the team, make sure they have what they need, and include them in post-game fun.

Pro Tip: Buy your goalie a beer afterward — it’s hockey etiquette!

✅ DO: Leave a Review

After the game, leave a review on MyPuck.com. Good goalies get more bookings and it helps other teams too.

❌ DON’T: Leave Them Hanging

Don’t ghost your spare goalie. If your plans change, update them ASAP through the platform.

❌ DON’T: Pay Outside the Platform

Always pay through MyPuck.com. It protects you and the goalie. Cash deals might seem easy but come with risk.

❌ DON’T: Expect a Miracle Every Time

A rent-a-goalie can’t always steal every game. Be realistic and focus on having fun.

Related: Top 5 reasons to hire a spare goalie

Good Etiquette Builds Good Hockey

The rent-a-goalie system works because teams and goalies respect each other. Be a good host and your team will never have to scramble for a goalie again.

Keep the Game Alive

Need to rent a goalie for your next game? Book now at MyPuck.com and play worry-free.