Beer League vs. Shinny: What’s the Best Rec Hockey Option for You?
If you’re an adult looking to get back on the ice, you’ll likely come across two main formats: beer league and shinny. Both are popular in Canada and offer something different depending on your skill level, schedule, and hockey goals. So which one should you choose? Let’s break it down.
What Is Beer League Hockey?
Beer league hockey is a nickname for organized adult recreational hockey leagues. These leagues are typically non-contact, co-ed or men’s, and often include multiple divisions based on skill level.
Key Features:
Fixed teams and weekly schedules
Jerseys and team names
Standings and playoffs
Refs, scorekeepers, and structured gameplay
Pros:
Team bonding and camaraderie
Regular ice time
Competitive structure (without being too serious)
Cons:
Requires commitment
Can get expensive (league fees, jerseys, etc.)
What Is Shinny Hockey?
Shinny is informal, pick-up style hockey. No teams, no refs, no standings. Just show up and play.
Key Features:
First-come, first-served
Mixed skill levels
No hitting or slap shots (usually)
Often organized by local arenas or community centres
Pros:
Flexible and casual
Great for practice and extra ice time
Less expensive
Cons:
No guaranteed ice time
Uneven teams and skill gaps
Can get chaotic if overcrowded
Which One Is Right for You?
Choose Beer League If You:
Want a consistent schedule
Enjoy playing on a team
Like competition and organized structure
Choose Shinny If You:
Want casual, drop-in games
Can’t commit to a full season
Want to focus on fun or individual skill-building
Why Not Both?
Many adult players do both! Play beer league with your regular team, and hit up shinny sessions to stay sharp or get in extra cardio. It’s the best of both hockey worlds.
Related: Why adult rec hockey is booming in Canada
What About Goalies?
Both beer league and shinny need goalies — and often struggle to find them. That’s where services like MyPuck.com come in. Whether you're short a goalie for your beer league or hosting a shinny night and need one, you can rent a reliable spare goalie quickly and easily.
Final Thoughts
There’s no right or wrong choice — just the format that fits your life and goals. Whether it’s a highly organized league or spontaneous shinny, the most important thing is to get on the ice and enjoy the game.
Need a goalie for your next game? Book one now at MyPuck.com