The Most Common Challenges Rent-a-Goalies Face
Rent-a-goalies are the unsung heroes of adult recreational hockey — stepping into unfamiliar locker rooms, facing unpredictable shooters, and saving games across Canada. But it’s not all glove saves and glory. Being a spare goalie comes with its fair share of challenges. Here’s what to expect, and how to tackle each obstacle like a true pro.
1. Last-Minute Game Requests
Rent-a-goalies often get called with just a few hours (or minutes) to spare.
How to handle it:
Keep your gear packed and ready at all times
Set your phone to alert for notifications from MyPuck.com
Be clear on your availability so you only get relevant offers
Related: How to become a rent-a-goalie
2. Unfamiliar Rinks and Teams
Every rink has quirks — weird boards, cold dressing rooms, bad lighting — and every team has different playing styles.
How to handle it:
Arrive early to get oriented
Ask the team for quick scouting info
Adjust quickly and focus on the basics: angles, rebound control, communication
3. Uneven Team Skill Levels
You might end up facing 40 shots a night — especially if you're filling in for a lower-skilled team playing in a high-skilled division.
How to handle it:
Stay composed under pressure
Focus on good positioning and tracking the puck
Let the team know you’ll do your best, but that support is key
4. Gear Wear and Tear
Multiple games per week mean extra wear on expensive goalie gear.
How to handle it:
Clean and dry your gear after every game
Reinforce high-stress areas (e.g., glove palms, straps)
Invest in backup gear if you plan to play often
5. Team Communication (or Lack Thereof)
Sometimes a team won’t tell you the dressing room, game time, or even their jersey colour.
How to handle it:
Use MyPuck.com to message teams directly
Ask questions in advance to avoid confusion
Confirm the address, start time, and arrival window
6. No Recognition or Gratitude
Some nights, you’ll stand on your head and still leave without a thank-you.
How to handle it:
Remember why you play: for love of the game
Appreciate the teams that show love — they’re the ones worth rebooking
Leave your info or profile link so teams can request you again
Related: The dos and don’ts of renting a goalie
7. The Mental Side of Being a Rent-a-Goalie
Being the only unfamiliar face on the ice can feel isolating. Plus, you’re always expected to be the hero.
How to handle it:
Focus on doing your best, not being perfect
Embrace the variety — it sharpens your game
Celebrate your saves, even if no one else does
Final Thoughts
Being a rent-a-goalie is rewarding, but it’s not always easy. The right mindset, preparation, and support network make all the difference. Tackle the challenges head-on, and you’ll not only become a better goalie — you’ll become an indispensable part of Canada’s rec hockey community.
Ready to step up in the crease? Join the MyPuck goalie network today